The loyalty landscape is undergoing rapid transformation — and financial institutions are positioned to benefit if they adapt quickly. With the U.S. loyalty market projected to grow from $23.57 billion in 2024 to $44.73 billion by 20291, bank and credit union loyalty is no longer just a retention tool. It is a strategic growth engine. Here are three trends shaping consumer expectations — and the opportunities they create for banks and credit unions.
Trend 1: Personalization Gets More Powerful — and More Sensitive
While personalization isn’t new, how consumers experience and respond to it is evolving. Personalized experiences are valued, but only when they are transparent and trustworthy. Financial institutions face a clear challenge: use data to be “helpful” without feeling invasive.
Marigold’s consumer trends research2 shows that the line between intriguing and “creepy” hinges on transparency: 52% of consumers find interest-specific messages “cool,” while 80% respond the same to personalized birthday offers.
Why it matters for financial institutions:
Financial institutions operate in a high-trust environment. When personalized experiences are transparent and contextually relevant, they drive loyalty, boost card engagement, and reinforce trust.
How to leverage this trend:
Provide clear explanations for personalized offers.
Example: “You spend often at grocery stores. Enjoy 5% cashback this week.”
Trend 2: Omnichannel & Frictionless Experiences Become Loyalty Differentiators
Strong bank and credit union loyalty today isn’t just about card rewards — it’s about the complete, connected experience.
Financial products are increasingly merging into merchant ecosystems, creating seamless, embedded journeys, such as card-linked offers at the point of sale3. Digital engagement is especially impactful: cardholders who engage digitally are 2.7× more likely to stay with their financial institution4. At the same time, market behavior is shifting. Non-prime consumers are spending more frequently, often making larger-ticket purchases, and showing greater resilience, intentionality, and need for convenience.
Why it matters for financial institutions:
This data emphasizes the increasing importance of well-designed programs. A frictionless experience — integrating card, mobile app, rewards, and merchant partnerships — is becoming a competitive requirement. When banking and rewards are embedded into everyday spending, loyalty becomes part of the cardholder’s routine.
How to leverage this trend:
Explore solutions that focus on engaging cardholders either at the point of sale or immediately following a transaction. For example, programs like ampliFI’s Fuel With Points or Checkout With Points capture the cardholder at the precise moment of spending, directly connecting the purchase action with the instant value of your rewards program. Alternatively, consider post-purchase engagement with a program like Pay With Points, which allows cardholders to immediately redeem rewards against a recent purchase, reinforcing the value proposition right after the transaction is complete.
Example: Save $0.50 off per gallon for up to 20 gallons at participating fuel providers.
Trend 3: Values-Driven Bank and Credit Union Loyalty Rises
Sustainability isn’t a secondary topic; it’s reshaping loyalty expectations. Across industries, brands are aligning rewards with sustainability goals, a shift driven largely by Millennials and Gen Z, who consistently prioritize environmental responsibility¹. As purpose-driven behavior grows, rewards tied to responsible purchasing and community impact are increasingly attractive.
Why it matters for financial institutions:
Community-rooted institutions like credit unions and regional banks can differentiate by connecting sustainability to spending behaviors, fostering emotional loyalty that goes beyond transactional rewards.
How to leverage this trend:
Partner with local charities and sustainable businesses.
Example: Redeem points towards local charities and give back to the community.
As the market nearly doubles in size by 2029, financial institutions that invest in modern programs — intelligent, omnichannel, and purpose-driven — will be best positioned to drive lasting cardholder engagement and long-term loyalty.
Let’s elevate cardholder engagement in 2026. Connect with our team by clicking the button below.
Sources:
1Research and Markets, United States Loyalty Programs Market
2Marigold, 2025 Consumer Trends Index global infographic
3PYMNTS, Why Experience – Not Credit – Is the New Moat in Consumer Finance
4The Financial Brand, Plastic Won’t Win Wallets – But Frictionless Experiences Will